Grease could promote flats on rollers if they slide instead of rolling. For sliders it could extend their life span if it decreases wear. The smoothest transmission I have felt was a variator with custom Teflon sliders.
I think there is a huge misunderstanding about rollers. To my mind the only reason why rollers are being called “rollers”, is because they are round. In fact - I am quite convinced rollers behave just like sliders under riding conditions.
Once the engine starts and the rollers get flung outwards, the rollers actually get “pinched” between the two separate surfaces at the inside of the variator - and the friction against the TWO sides of the variator makes it almost impossible for the rollers to roll forward.
In other words - if the rollers was just in contact with one surface at the inside of the variator, it would roll outwards under acceleration. In reality the second contact surface cancels the roller’s ability to roll forward - specially under acceleration the rollers will tend to slide forward instead of rolling forward.
In short - I think the usual flat spots on older rollers is proof of what actually happens to rollers under riding conditions. It usually slides forward, specially under stress - instead of rolling forward.
I think the only reasons why grease will cause more wear on rollers are:
1. When a thick (more sticky) get used. (This type of grease might restrict the rollers to roll under all conditions).
2. When a thinner grease - like CV joint grease becomes like a grinding paste due to dust.
My intention is to stick to the grease for the time being, and see what happens within the next 1000 km.